By Jarrod Mamo.
Throughout our practice over the last year, we have seen a significant growth in the development and reliance on AI technology from a client/social basis and on a professional basis. Considering it is so easy to access, and much more tailored to a request that a Google search, it is no wonder that AI is being relied upon so much.
We are seeing a growth of instructions being given after embellishment of AI, or even positions/ideas being put forward after consultation with AI. The individuals who take this approach are often surprised when we advise that their position based on AI is wrong and based on fabricated information, and they incur legal fees in us responding to the issue. Any “advice” given by AI on a legal matter should never be considered as factual without proper corroboration. There is a reason why a client engages a lawyer for their matter, and that is to provide legal advice.
In a professional sense, we can look at the matter of Mertz & Mertz (No 3) [2025] FedCFamC1A 222 where a paralegal prepared a document using AI which ultimately resulted in submissions being made using other cases/precedents that simply did not exist. This prepared work was not reviewed by the instructing solicitor or acting Counsel. All three practitioners involved were referred to their professional disciplinary bodies for review of their conduct.
Not only does using AI for submissions or Court documents risk misleading the Court, there are also risks that the individual involved could be shown to be publicly communicating an account of family law proceedings (breaching section 114Q of the Family Law Act 1975), or even waiving legal professional privilege.
If you wish to contact us for a discussion about a Family Law matter, please contact us for an obligation-free initial consultation.